Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting Gatsby's. We'd love to have your feedback!


Type to search our menu...

You are submitting your information to Gatsby's and Popmenu, which powers this site and is sponsoring this giveaway. Popmenu's and apply.

Our Latest Reviews

Steve Wiederkehr 5 months ago

The Pork Tenderloin

Perfect as usual. Staff is the Best in Indy

Vicki 10 months ago

Gatsby's House Pizza

This will be my new not the 'norm' go-to pizza. Loved, loved, loved it!!

Jon 11 months ago


Good food , EXCELLENT service!

Katieclaire1975 over 1 year ago

Gatsby's Chicken Cordon Bleu

For the last 18 years my absolute favorite when walking in these doors...

Debbra A almost 2 years ago


I called and put order in then picked up order. Wings, spinach dip, sirloin dinner. All was great! First time I will be back for sure. Staff was very curious.

Cora 8 months ago

Gatsby's House Pizza


Diane 10 months ago

Gatsby's House Pizza

This pizza is the best I’ve ever eaten!!! I’m a pescatarian, so I just say “hold the bacon bits”

Vicki about 1 year ago

BYO Sandwich

We just started going back to Gatsby's a month or so ago since the COVID shutdown and have only been twice, so far the food has been great but the service even better. We went on a Friday night in May and the one whole east side of the room was full,,,mostly kids and a few parents (the new section had not open yet). We almost didn't stay as we were sure it would take forever to get our order taken and food but after about 5 min or so Erin came up took our drink order then food order. We watched her and another gal (we had her the 1st time, wish I remembered her name as we really like her as well) work the whole floor and never seem to miss a beat nor feel overwhelmed with the large crowd. I know it helps that you have extra people that bring out the food which helps servers. We were disappointed at 1st when we saw the boatload of kids (although they were well behave), as this was one reason we decided to check out Gatsby again since it was adult only, nothing against them, but at times we like to eat at bars so we know it won't have to hear babies crying, toddler's screaming etc. so was glad when Erin said that one side will be open soon for family dining. We plan on making Gatsby go to bar.

Reuben over 1 year ago


The fried mushrooms are perfect - always crisp and delicious!