Appetizers | Quesadillas | Wings | Baskets | Soups | Standard Sides | Premium Sides | BYO Sandwich | Sandwiches & Wraps | Pizzas | Entrees | Salads | Beverages | Drinks
Appetizers
Chips and Salsa
Fresh made salsa and tortilla chips
Kettle Chips
A thinly sliced whole potato fried to perfection, lightly seasoned and served with your choice of dipping sauce.
Garlic Breadsticks
Four soft breadsticks, served warm with marinara or cheese sauce or both for an additional charge
Mushrooms
Fresh cut button mushrooms dipped in Gatsby's special batter then deep fried to perfection. Served with ranch.
Battered Onion Rings
Sweet onions battered, fried and piled high in a basket
Mozzarella Sticks
Six crunchy, breaded mozzarella cheese sticks served with marinara sauce
Poppers
Six juicy jalapeño peppers breaded and filled with cheddar and fried to golden perfection. Served with house made ranch.
Cheese Fries
Delicious fries covered with your choice of shredded Monterrey Jack and cheddar or nacho cheese topped off with diced tomatoes, bacon bits and scallions for supreme flavor.
Loaded Potato Skins
Baked potatoes scooped out and topped with cheese, bacon, and scallions. Served with ranch or sour cream.
Butterflied Shrimp
Twelve delicious breaded and butterflied shrimp served with cocktail sauce or tossed in our hot or mild sauce.
Calamari
Fright Light and Crisp. Served with sweet Thai chili sauce.
Chicken Cordon Bleu Tenders
Slivered chicken wrapped in ham and Swiss cheese, hand-breaded, topped with Gatsby's Alfredo sauce, scallions, and shredded Parmesan.
Supreme Nachos
Tortilla chips loaded with your choice of chicken or beef chili then smothered with cheese, jalapenos, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, scallions and black olives.
Served with salsa and sour cream.
With Steak $
Fajita Nachos
Grilled chicken or steak topped with green onions, tomato, green peppers, shredded cheese and nacho cheese.
Served with salsa and sour cream.
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
A blend of cheese, spinach, artichoke hearts and seasonings served with tortilla chips, pita bread, or both.
Quesadillas
Served with house-made salsa and sour cream.
Four Cheese
A grilled tortilla folded and stuffed with a mix of provolone, Colby, Jack, and mozzarella.
With Chicken $

With Steak $

With Shrimp $

Vegetarian Option $
Spinach and Artichoke
Mozzarella cheese, fresh spinach, onion, and chopped artichoke hearts
Wings
Traditional, Bone-In, or Hand-Breaded Boneless
Hot, Mild, BBQ, Hot Garlic, Garlic Parmesan, Thai Chili, Teriyaki, Sriracha, Mango Habanero, and a choice of Ranch or House-made Bleu Cheese.
(6) | (12) | (18)
Add (4) celery for an additional cost
Baskets
Chicken Tenders | Fish | Shrimp | Clams
A generous portion of your choice of hand-breaded chicken tenders, breaded fish, breaded shrimp, or breaded clams served with fries and coleslaw.
Soups
Served with crackers.
Cup | Bowl
House Chili
French Onion
Soup du Jour
Standard Sides
a la carte
Potato Salad
Pasta Salad
Coleslaw
Cottage Cheese
Broccoli
Tots*
Fries*
Potato Chips
Fruit
Baked Potato*
*Load your baked potato, fries, or tots for an additional cost!
Premium Sides
a la carte
Sweet Potato Fries
Waffle Fries*
Onion Rings
Side Salad
Kettle Chips
BYO Sandwich
Kick your sandwich up a notch with Cajun seasoning at no extra charge. Go ahead...we won't judge ya!
Choose a Handmade, hearty beef patty, cooked to order or a breaded or grilled chicken breast
Served on a Kaiser bun and comes with lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion, and mayo or BBQ sauce and choice of cheese: American, pepper jack, provolone, Swiss, blue cheese crumbles or feta.



extra cheese | grilled onion | bacon | mushrooms | fried egg | chili | jalapenos | banana peppers

Served with your choice of one side dish. Premium sides for an additional cost.
Sandwiches & Wraps
All sandwiches come with your choice of one standard side. Or choose any premium side for an additional cost.
Philly
Thinly sliced Philly steak or sliced chicken smothered in sautéed onion, mushrooms, and Provolone cheese stacked high on a fresh hoagie roll.
Gyro
Lamb | Chicken | Steak
Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, feta, and tzatziki sauce on a soft pita bread or in a wrap.
Crusted Romano Chicken
This house favorite has a fresh chicken breast breaded with our
secret seasonings and served with your choice of toppings on a fresh kaiser roll.
Pulled BBQ Pork
Slow roasted BBQ pork topped with blended shredded cheeses and
onion. Served piping hot on a fresh Kaiser roll.
Cuban
Sliced ham, turkey, and pork with pickle, mustard, tomato, onion and
Swiss cheese served on a toasted hoagie roll.
Fish Sandwich
Tasty tilapia filet served grilled or beer battered with lettuce,
tomato, onion and tartar sauce on a toasted Kaiser roll.
BLT
This sandwich is loaded with bacon, lettuce, mayo, and tomato and
served on your choice of toasted bread or in a wrap.
Reuben
Corned beef piled high and topped with Swiss cheese and kraut,
served on toasted Rye bread with Thousand Island dressing on the side.
Club
Sliced turkey and ham mounded on top of lettuce, tomato, Swiss
and American cheeses, bacon and mayo. Served on your choice of bread or in a wrap.
French Dip
Thinly sliced beef piled high on a toasted hoagie roll and topped with Provolone cheese served with au jus for dipping.
Ham and Cheese Sub
Sliced ham and your choice of cheese served hot or cold with
shredded lettuce, tomato, mayo and onion on your choice of hoagie or in a wrap.
The Pork Tenderloin
Breaded or grilled with your choice of toppings.
Add cajun for an extra little spicy kick.
Add Cheese for an additional cost
Chicken Wrap
Chicken breast, grilled or breaded, with lettuce, tomato, onion and a blend of cheeses. Wrapped in a warm tortilla. Get your chicken buffalo or Cajun for a spicy kick or go for the popular Southwest style!
Greek Wrap
Greens with cucumber, feta cheese tomato, black olive, pepperoncini
and onion with house-made Greek dressing.
Add chicken for an additional cost.
Fajita Wrap
Grilled chicken or steak, sauteed peppers, onions, and tomato. Lightly seasoned and served in a warm tortilla
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled or breaded chicken, crisp greens, onion, tomato, feta cheese and creamy caesar dressing. Wrapped in a warm flour tortilla.
Veggie Wrap
Fresh cucumber, tomato, cheese, avocado, carrots, celery and onions mixed with shredded lettuce and house dressing. Wrapped in a warm flour tortilla.
Pizzas
Four Cheese
Thin cracker crust, marinara sauce, and Provolone, Mozzarella, Monterey Jack, and cheddar.
10" | 14"
Build Your Own Pizza
10" | 14

Toppings available for an additional cost.

Thin cracker crust with your choice of any topping:
Ham, sausage, bacon, chicken, green peppers, banana peppers, pineapple, tomato, cheese, white onion, red onion, black or green olives, feta, spinach, artichoke hearts, mushrooms or jalapenos.

Sauces: marinara, BBQ, alfredo, garlic & olive oil.
The Carnivore
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, and cheese.
10" | 14"
The Super Deluxe
Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives and cheese
10" | 14"
Gatsby's House Pizza
Our cracker crust brushed with garlic & olive oil then layered with mushrooms, diced tomato, onion, feta, artichoke chips, mozzarella cheese, spinach and sprinkled with bacon bits.
10" | "14
Entrees
All entrees served with your choice of soup or salad.
Gatsby's Chicken Cordon Bleu
Grilled chicken breast with ham and Swiss cheese over penne pasta topped with alfredo sauce.
Pasta Diablo
Our signature Pasta Diablo is prepared with penne pasta in a creamy, spicy red sauce and topped with your choice of chicken or shrimp or both and served with a garlic breadstick.
Chicken | Shrimp | Both
Chicken Parmesan
Fresh chicken breast breaded with our secret seasonings and Romano mix then topped with mozzarella cheese and a zesty marinara sauce tossed in a bed of penne pasta. Served with a garlic breadstick.
Grilled Salmon
Fresh grilled salmon served with your choice of side and Texas toast.
Sirloin Steak
A juicy, tender sirloin cooked to order. Served with your choice of side and Texas toast. Try it black & blue, Cajun style or french onion and mozzarella.
Salads
Served with your choice of pita bread or garlic breadstick. Ask your server about half-portion salads.

Dressings:
Thousand Island | Bleu Cheese | Ranch | Fat Free Ranch | Honey Mustard | House | Italian | Hot Bacon | Greek | Caesar | French | Balsamic | Poppyseed | Vinegar & Oil
House Salad
Mixed greens, cucumber, tomato, bacon and tortilla strips. Served with Gatsby’s house dressing.
Chicken Salad
Chicken* (grilled, breaded), shredded cheese, diced tomato, and onion, then placed
on a fresh bed of greens.
*Try it buffalo or cajun style!
Teriyaki Salad
Crisp greens topped with grilled teriyaki chicken, wonton noodles, diced tomato,
green onions and mandarin oranges.
Chicken Caesar Salad
Mixed greens, onion, croutons, tomato and parmesan cheese with our very own creamy Caesar dressing served on the side.
Substitute a salmon filet for an additional charge
Taco Salad
Taco shell piled high with mixed greens, jalapeno, tomato,black olives and blended cheese. With your choice of chicken, steak or beef chili. (excludes pita/bread stick)
Add Chicken | Chili | Steak for an additional cost.
Chef Salad
A refreshing mix of turkey, ham, bacon, onion, tomato, cheese, and egg all on a mound of fresh lettuce.
Greek Salad
Mixed greens with cucumber, feta cheese, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini and onions with
house-made Greek dressing.
Spinach Salad
Fresh spinach piled high and topped with bacon, red onion, egg, mushrooms and hot bacon dressing on the side.
Cobb Salad
Mixed greens topped with grilled chicken, blue cheese crumbles, sunflower seeds, onion, tomato, egg, and bacon.
Crusted Romano Chicken Salad
A fresh chicken breast breaded with our very own Romano seasonings set atop a bed of fresh greens, tomato, egg, bacon, tortilla strips, parmesan cheese, and scallions.
Beverages
Sodas - Free Refills
Pepsi | Diet Pepsi | Mt. Dew | Mug Root-beer | Dr. Pepper | Sierra Mist | Lemonade | Hot Tea | Coffee (regular or decaf)
Bottled Water
Juices
Orange | Pineapple | Cranberry | Grapefruit
Red Bull
Regular or Sugar Free
Ask about available flavors!
Drinks
Beer
We proudly serve Indiana Beer
Tequila
Teremana
Whiskey
Proper 12
Slane
Vodka
Kettle One Cucumber Mint
Ciroc S. Citrus
Ciroc S. Watermelon
Smirnoff Apple













logo menu photos contactus directions mailinglist about specialsandevents directions twitter yelp facebook foursquare tripadvisor urbanspoon